Monday, March 13, 2006

Robots In Space

Some of this actually made the lamestream media, so there may actually be a tiny fraction of the population already aware of the great science returned this week by our fleet of robotic explorers.

Their successes serve to underscore the idiocy of ramping up a manned space program with no tangible objectives by gutting the budget for future robotic missions. Given a choice between idiocy and rationality in managing this nation’s expenditures on space science, of course our politicians — led, I’m sorry to report, by George W. Bush — are choosing idiocy.

Sigh.

The big news of the week was from the Cassini mission, where NASA announced the discovery of liquid water on Enceladus, one of the strange moons of Saturn. The graphic at right is from NASA, and shows one possible mechanism the explains the (very much) unexpected presence of liquid water in the cold environs of Saturn.

From NASA’s press release:

As Saturn’s active moon Enceladus continues to spew icy particles into space, scientists struggle to understand the mechanics of what is going on beneath the fractured south polar terrain. This graphic illustrates key aspects of the model proposed by the Cassini imaging science team in a paper published in the journal Science on March 10, 2006.

The model shows how proposed underground reservoirs of pressurized liquid water above 273 degrees Kelvin (0 degrees Celsius) could fuel geysers that send jets of icy material into the skies above the moon’s south pole. In the graphic, the vent to the surface pierces one of the “tiger stripe” fractures seen in Cassini views of the southern polar terrain (see Tiger Stripes Up Close for a look at the tiger stripes). Temperatures increase with depth.

Some combination of internal radioactive decay and flexing — perhaps concentrated within the tiger stripe fractures and brought about by the particular characteristics of Enceladus' orbit — is implicated as the source of the heat creating the liquid reservoirs. However, it is not yet clear how the deep interior of Enceladus functions, nor whether the moon is fully differentiated (separated into layers, with rock at the center and ice outside).

The main significance of liquid water is of course that its presence is one of the key precursors for life-as-we-know-it (LAWKI), meaning life based on carbon chemistry, with a major dependence on water as the matrix in which much of that chemsitry occurs. On earth, under the conditions hypothesized by the NASA scientists to explain liquid water on Enceladus, there would be life. This certainly doesn’t “prove” that Enceladus harbors LAWKI lifeforms — but it sure makes folks much more curious to find out if that’s the case.

Something you probably won’t hear from the lamestream media: this finding on Enceladus is a splendid example of why robots make better space explorers than humans. Cassini will spend several years studying Saturn and it’s moons; a manned mission could spend weeks at best. Cassini is free to spend months in space as it wanders from one moon to another; a manned mission couldn’t realistically do that. And Cassini can visit repeatedly (it will be back to Enceladus in 2008), whereas a manned mission would be little more than a one night stand. These capabilities overwhelm the cognitive and observational superiorities of humans — and the better our technology for instrumentation gets, the greater that gap becomes.

In other space news, the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter (MRO) successfully inserted itself into orbit around Mars.

From the NASA press release:

The spacecraft, Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter, will provide more science data than all previous Mars missions combined.

Signals received from the spacecraft at 2:16 p.m. Pacific Time after it emerged from its first pass behind Mars set off cheers and applause in control rooms at NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Pasadena, Calif., and at Lockheed Martin Space Systems, Denver.

"This is a great milestone to have accomplished, but it’s just one of many milestones before we can open the champagne,” said Colleen Hartman, deputy associate administrator for NASA’s Science Mission Directorate. “Once we are in the prime science orbit, the spacecraft will perform observations of the atmosphere, surface, and subsurface of Mars in unprecedented detail."

The spacecraft traveled about 500 million kilometers (310 million miles) to reach Mars after its launch from Florida on Aug. 12, 2005. It needed to use its main thrusters as it neared the planet in order to slow itself enough for Mars' gravity to capture it. The thruster firing began while the spacecraft was still in radio contact with Earth, but needed to end during a tense half hour of radio silence while the spacecraft flew behind Mars.

"Our spacecraft has finally become an orbiter,” said JPL’s Jim Graf, project manager for the mission. “The celebration feels great, but it will be very brief because before we start our main science phase, we still have six months of challenging work to adjust the orbit to the right size and shape."

For the next half-year, the mission will use hundreds of carefully calculated dips into Mars' atmosphere in a process called “aerobraking.” This will shrink its orbit from the elongated ellipse it is now flying, to a nearly circular two-hour orbit. For the mission’s principal science phase, scheduled to begin in November, the desired orbit is a nearly circular loop ranging from 320 kilometers (199 miles) to 255 kilometers (158 miles) in altitude, lower than any previous Mars orbiter. To go directly into such an orbit instead of using aerobraking, the mission would have needed to carry about 70 percent more fuel when it launched.

The instruments on Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter will examine the planet from this low-altitude orbit. A spectrometer will map water-related minerals in patches as small as a baseball infield. A radar instrument will probe for underground layers of rock and water. One telescopic camera will resolve features as small as a card table. Another will put the highest-resolution images into broader context. A color camera will monitor the entire planet daily for changes in weather. A radiometer will check each layer of the atmosphere for variations in temperature, water vapor and dust.

"The missions currently at Mars have each advanced what we know about the presence and history of water on Mars, and one of the main goals for Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter is to decipher when water was on the surface and where it is now,” said JPL’s Dr. Richard Zurek, project scientist for the mission. “Water is essential for life, so that will help focus future studies of whether Mars has ever supported life."

The orbiter can radio data to Earth at up to 10 times the rate of any previous Mars mission. Besides sending home the pictures and other information from its own investigations, it will relay data from surface missions, including NASA’s Phoenix Mars Scout scheduled for launch in 2007 and Mars Science Laboratory in development for 2009.

Scientists studying Mars have been waiting for MRO with great anticipation — I think almost in equal measure for the instruments MRO carries (and will use in long-term observations) and for the added communications capabilities MRO brings to the Mars neighborhood. MRO is partly an “upgrade” to current robots already at Mars, and even to robots yet to arrive. A poor analogy: its a bit like what happens to a town when they first get a telephone system installed.

And last, but certainly not least, the plucky Martian Rovers (Spirit and Opportunity) are still rambling around on the surface of Mars, doing great science work every day.

From the NASA Press Release:

The panoramic camera aboard NASA’s Mars Exploration Rover Opportunity acquired this panorama of the “Payson” outcrop on the western edge of “Erebus” Crater during Opportunity’s sol 744 (Feb. 26, 2006). From this vicinity at the northern end of the outcrop, layered rocks are observed in the crater wall, which is about 1 meters (3.3 feet) thick. The view also shows rocks disrupted by the crater-forming impact event and subjected to erosion over time.

To the left of the outcrop, a flat, thin layer of spherule-rich soils overlies more outcrop materials. The rover is currently traveling down this “road” and observing the approximately 25-meter (82-foot) length of the outcrop prior to departing Erebus crater.

The panorama camera took 28 separate exposures of this scene, using four different filters. The resulting panorama covers about 90 degrees of terrain around the rover. This approximately true-color rendering was made using the camera’s 753-nanometer, 535-nanometer and 423-nanometer filters. Image-to-image seams have been eliminated from the sky portion of the mosaic to better simulate the vista a person standing on Mars would see.

It would be hard to overstate the contributions these two little machines have made to our understanding of Mars. As in most scientific investigations, their discoveries have raised a lot more questions than they answered — but they sure have answered a lot! Thanks to them, we now know for sure something we’ve long suspected: the Martian surface once had standing and flowing water. For over two years now (long past the 90 day design lifetime), the rovers have been patiently exploring, returning panoramic photos like the one above, microscopic photos of rocks and minerals, detailed spectrographs at both long and short range, and much more. Amazing gadgets, they are…

Sunday, March 12, 2006

Puppy Journal

And in the blink of an eye, they are puppies. :-)

They bark, they bite, they pounce, they wag their tails, and they tumble ass over tea kettle. They make each other cry. They are inquisitive. They are underfoot. They are developing their personalities (though these are subject to major change as the weeks go by).

Pink and Purple Girls are the “Hey, what is that?” puppies. First to do everything.

Blue Boy is the most alert. He shakes and “kills” his toys. He protests when things don’t go his way. Case in point. He wants under the bed. I blocked the way. He wants under the bed. HE WANTS UNDER THE BED.

Green Boy is already marching to the beat of his own drummer. When his brothers and sisters are awake, he is asleep. When he is awake, they are asleep. He explores and plays by himself (or torments sleeping puppies).

White and Yellow Boys are my “good boys”. They are the “What are we doing now?” puppies. They are good to cuddle, game to eat, love to sleep, and willing to do whatever the other puppies are doing.

They are four-weeks old today and I don’t know how much weigh. The pan they sit in on the scale is the perfect size to block the corner of the bed (and foil Blue Boy’s attempts to get under the bed).

Last week I wrote that I would be starting the weaning process. I wasn’t going to waste my time fixing their first meals if they weren’t ready for it. So on Tuesday night I tried them on water. They were all curious about the dish and dipped their noses in it. Good sign. I decided that I would fix them their first meal on Wednesday when they were 3 1/2 weeks old.

Wednesday was the night of the flood. Flood #1 occurred after school when I was putting down a clean bowl of water in the laundry room (dogs come and go in and out of the house through the laundry room - I fix their meals in there - Booster bath is in there) and some blonde CBR head knocked it out of my hand. Much cursing ensued because I cleaned this room when I was home sick. Flood #2 occurred in the puppy room when I was putting Picabo’s dinner down and she jumped up and then down into her water dish sending water everywhere. More cursing (sorry you had to hear that puppies). I started a load of puppy laundry and fixed everyone else their dinner. Trip #1 and I carried the Field Spaniels' dishes into the dog room. Trip #2 and I carried Hope and True’s dishes into the dog room. Trip #3 was to put Mercy’s food down on the laundry room floor (she is 13-years old and eats in there. She eats a little, takes a break by going out into the yard, comes back and eats some more - it takes her about 20 minutes to eat). Trip #3 into the laundry room and splish splash there is water everywhere! The washer filled, overfilled, and overflowed! I rushed over to shut off the machine but the water kept flowing. The main water shut-off valve is right there so I shut water off to the house. I am speechless. No cursing this time. I put Mercy all the way outside to eat and grabbed my mop. You know that dog hair that collects under the washer and dryer? You know that dirt and hair that we never clean up often enough? There was my sparkling clean laundry room floor with all that dirt and hair floating on it. I mopped up enough water to stop the splashing, hauled the Booster Bath into the kitchen, and literally tossed my used-to-be clean but now soggy rugs out the back door (where they still sit in a frozen lump). The rest of the evening was spent cleaning the laundry room (it ain’t easy pulling out the washer and dryer) and puzzling out what was wrong with the machine (cold water valve is stuck open for some reason). I turned off water to just the washer and turned water back on to the house. Oh, to raise a litter without a washer. Not good. But not that bad. The washer works, it just has to be manually filled with water. I can do that with a hose from the laundry tub. Not convenient but workable until the local repairman gets a day off from his regular job. He’s supposed to be here this coming Friday after school. Needless to say, the puppies did not get their first meal on Wednesday.

Sometime during the school day on Thursday, it dawned on me that I wasn’t sick. I felt better than I had in over a month. I went home in good spirits. I opened the front door and a wave of something foul-smelling hit me. My FS were all there fine and well. I went into the puppy room and Picabo was sick. She had thrown up twice and had one bout of diarrhea. More cleaning up but this time without an easy to use washer. Picabo didn’t have a temperature and her gums were nice and pink. She was quite green around the gills and you could tell by looking at her that she didn’t feel well. I shrugged it off to the stress of raising a litter. This same thing happened to her with her first litter at exactly the same time. My plan was to let her fast until morning, put her on a bland diet, and of course, I would feed her puppies. If that didn’t work, I did have the pills the vet gave me when this happened before. Pills are a last resort because of the drug transference through her milk. It is now Sunday and she is bright and perky but not 100%. That little bit of extra weight I have been working so hard to keep on her is gone. She is positively gaunt. She is eating a 1/2 portion of her food with cottage cheese. She isn’t vomiting anymore but her stools are still really loose (but she goes hours and hours between poops). She is drinking water well. She will be fine. She just can’t bounce back as quickly as she could if she wasn’t under this stress.

So the puppies were given their first dog food meal on Thursday night and they think I am one heck of a cook. :-) My weaning formula is:

1. Put the kettle on to boil.

2. Put a small amount of mom’s kibble in a mixing bowl.

3. Cover with boiling water.

4. Let soak until cool.

5. Smash it up with a potato masher.

6. For six puppies, divide it into two shallow dishes. I’ve been using the little dishes that come with frozen entrees.

7. Pour a generous amount of either goat’s milk, buttermilk, or Esbilac on top. I’m using Esbilac Goat’s Milk. It takes one can per day.

8. As days go by, reduce the milk product and add things like yogurt and cottage cheese. Reduce the amount of mashing. If mom is getting puppy food, switch the puppies over to adult food once they get the hang of eating and digesting dog food.

These puppies have taken to food really well. Thursday night they basically lapped up the milk. This morning they actually ate the food. Speaking of mornings, now that they are eating (and pooping real poop), the 30 minutes extra minutes I need in the morning to take care of them is now 45 minutes (and 60 would be better). The puppies are more fun now but they are also a lot more physical work. Karen Miller called me Saturday morning and asked how things were going. I said weakly, “Oh, fine”. LOL I can’t help but think of the song lyric, “So you had a bad day”. :-) Actually, its not so bad. It could be a lot worse. Things just got a little complicated this week. :-)

Sheila Miller

Wolftree Acres

Nevada, USA

sdmiller@the-onramp.net

http://www.wolftreeacres.homestead.com

Wierd Weather

One doesn’t normally think of San Diego as the kind of place where one is likely to run into rain, much less hail and sleet — not to mention sub-freezing temperatures.

Yesterday we had all of that, and in astonishing abundance. Shortly after dawn we noticed the first examples of water falling from the sky and hitting the ground with a “tink” instead of a “splash” — hail. The hail was pea-sized at its largest, so it was far from threatening (thankfully!). But there certainly was a lot of it — all of the “white stuff” you see in these photos is accumulated hail, not snow.

The really intense hail started falling locally at just before noon yesterday; it continued intermittently will into the evening. At one point we had close to an inch of the stuff on the ground, and at the moment I drove down the hill to go rescue my blog server, there was so much ice on our driveway that my pickup actually broke loose on the slope and skidded ten feet or so downhill.

This is a brand-new experience for us in southern California. We’ve seen plenty of this sort of stuff in other places (such as New Jersey and Indiana, where Debbie and I grew up), but here?

What’s up with this global warming stuff, anyway? Sure doesn’t look like it on the evidence of the past few days!

Wrapping Complexity

As I was driving home from repairing my blog’s server, I got to thinking about the complexity of the technology that I’m using as a hobby. The cabinet in my friend’s basement contains two servers (with a few hundred gigabytes of storage between them), three routers, two network switches, and a dedicated “cabinet management” single-board computer. Between all of that gear there are several billion transistors and several trillion bits of stored data. The software I’m using, including the operating system, has something on the order of 100 million lines of source code. There’s also several thousand feet of cable, hundreds of connectors, and on and on. Basically it’s a pretty darned complex piece of equipment, full of very advanced technology (especially the hard disks and the CPU chips).

When I was a kid, I had a not-too-dissimilar hobby, at least at first blush: I was into audio and radio electronics. But the “systems” that I worked with had at most a handful of active devices (tubes, in my case — I couldn’t afford transistors, which were middling exotic at that point), and a few dozen other components in a really complex design. There were, of course, no computers involved, so no software at all.

So today’s hobby involves systems with something like 10 to the 13th “parts” (including software), and in my hobby as a kid something like 10 squared parts. That’s a ratio of 10 to the 11th in numbers of parts — something like the difference between traveling one inch and making 300 round trips to the moon. That’s a huge difference! But the difference in complexity is even larger — much, much larger, in fact, because the more parts you have, the more ways in which they can interact.

In my own life — and it ain’t over yet — the increase in the complexity of the machines that we use every day is so large that its hard to grasp and accept. It’s also amazing to me that all this new stuff, as complex as it is, can be used by ordinary people who understand nothing at all about how it works. You don’t have to be a programmer to enjoy a personal computer, or to use it in your work. You don’t have to be an electrical engineer to drive a modern car, with its thousands of electronic devices. A big part, I think, of the success of modern technology is the way we’ve been able to “wrap” it so that ordinary people can use it…

Something to think about the next time you watch your amazing television — the one with millions of transistors, gobs of software, and in many cases even hard disks for storage (that’s how Tivo works, folks)…

Blog Problems

The gods must be crazy. Or at least all pissed off at me. My evidence for this: my blog’s server had a meltdown around noon on Saturday, and the problem wasn’t the usual kind of thing, where a single failure occurred. No, we couldn’t have a normal kind of problem with our server. Of course not. We had to have a special sort of problem…

The first symptom was easy enough to observe: the blog stopped responding. Disappeared into the proverbial black hole. Some quick testing with the old standby “ping” utility confirmed that the server was definitely not alive, in the sense that the operating system was not booted and operating. At this point I couldn’t tell if the server hardware was operating or not.

If you followed my adventures in remote hosting in December and January, you know that I built a cabinet with remote reset and remote power-cycling capability, specifically to deal with situations like this. So with good cheer, and thanking myself for my foresight, I tried a remote reset of the server.

Nothing happened.

OK. Well, that’s why we also built the remote power cycling, because sometimes hardware gets “hung up” in funny modes that only a power cycling can cure. But that’s rare, so I’m beginning to worry at this point. Tried the power cycling.

Nothing happened.

Oops.

Now this looks bad, and most likely it means an outright hardware failure. Or, just maybe, it means that the remote reset and/or power cycling stuff I built didn’t work. And my server is a 40 minute drive from my house, where all my tools and spare parts are. Sigh. Off I go, “down the hill” as we say, out of Lawson Valley, through Jamul, and off to my remote hosting site (in my friend’s basement). Time to grab the server, take it back home, and hook the sucker up to a test environment.

Absolutely nothing happened. No video, no POST beeps. Something quite fundamental — power supply, CPU, etc. — must be broken. Took all the daughter boards out (except video), disconnected all the drives, etc., and tried booting again. This time I started getting really weird symptoms — I could see it starting to boot, then at random points failing and restarting. If I left it in this mode long enough, eventually the boot sequence would get to the point where it figured out that the drives were missing — but even then, after some random interval it would fail again. Ok. This was looking like either (a) some noise or intermittent failure in the power supply, or (b) a less-likely motherboard or CPU problem. Betting on the power supply, I drove back down the hill to a computer store, picked up a new 350W power supply (for $39!), and drove back home to install it. That took two hours, almost entirely for the driving.

With the new power supply, now the server booted very reliably. Ok, I must have guessed correctly on the power supply! Yippee! I figured I could just put it all back together and everything would be wonderful.

Oops. When I plugged everything back in and rebooted, I got an alarming message from my RAID board during power-up: one of my hard drives was either disconnected or not operable. And it wasn’t disconnected, I quickly figured out — it was really dead. Sheesh! Two problems at the same time!! This is very unlikely to be a random occurrence — much more likely is that either the power supply problem caused the drive to fail, or the drive problem caused the power supply to fail. If it’s the former, then I can most likely look forward to other early failures, as the most likely scenario there is some voltage was out-of-spec high, stressing everything connected to it. Not good. So I’m hoping it’s the latter case — the hard drive failed in some bizarre manner that took out the power supply (though this was a high-end power supply that really should be immune to anything the load might do to it). But, since I had no spare disk drives of the right type lying about, I had to go down the hill again, this time to Fry’s electronics, to pick up a new drive and install it. After I did that, the server booted, rebuilt its RAID array, and started up normally. Hooray! And this morning I reinstalled it, which is how you can read this…

Though this was a real pain in the neck sort of experience, I can’t help but think how amazing it is that in America, even someone like me living “out in the boonies” can get fast and inexpensive access to some of the most advanced technology in the world (hard disks, if you’re not already aware of it, are chock full of things that were in the realm of science fiction just a few years ago). This entire event, from failure to repair, took less than 8 hours (the server was down longer only because I didn’t want to wake my friend late Saturday night or early Sunday morning). In another country, it might take weeks to get such components — and I’d have paid a lot more for them. Here, even late on a Saturday evening, I just walked into a store (have you ever been in Fry’s Electronics? It’s quite an experience if you’re in the least geekly…), pick what I want from a large selection, and drive back home with my purchase. Think of all the things that had to happen for me to be able to do that: the scientists and engineers who invented the technology, the operations folks who took that technology from a lab to high-volume production, the distribution channels that got it to San Diego, etc. All of that so that my silly blog server could be repaired quickly and easily. Pretty close to miraculous, I’d say…

Wednesday, March 8, 2006

Iran

All this bad news from Iran might just be good news in disguise:

The Russians have given up trying to find a compromise, and have joined ranks with the U.S. and Europe. The Europeans (yes, even the French and the Germans) are making stern noises and telling Iran to watch out for the “consequences” if they keep pursuing nuclear weapons. An Iranian official tells leaders of other Muslim countries all about how the Iranians pulled the wool over the European’s eyes when they denied what we all knew was the truth — that they are in fact developing nuclear weapons. The Iranian president, openly, repeatedly, and forcefully calls for the destruction and “wiping out” of Israel. And finally, today, responding to Cheney’s (wonderful) AIPAC speech, the Iranians are directly threating the U.S.

That all sounds like uniformly bad news, right?

I think not. In fact, I think every bit of that was completely predictable if you accept as fact that the Iranian government is actually directed by the mad mullahs — and only the most committed ostrich would claim otherwise. The mullahs have made no secret of their radical Muslim beliefs. In particular, they have reiterated on many occasions their belief that all non-Muslims should either be killed or enslaved — and their definition of “non-Muslim” means, really, anyone who is not a Muslim of the same radical flavor as themselves.

So how can any of this bad news really be good news?

Until quite recently, the Iranians have played a quite effective PR game. As their envoy recently said (at a meeting he thought was private), they’ve been regularly pulling wool over the eyes of the Europeans, and anyone else who would rather believe a comfortable lie than the uncomfortable truth. This PR game has allowed the leftish liberals (in any country) to make the claim that the cowboys of the world were grossly overreacting to the peaceful Iranian intentions. After the news of the past few weeks, that’s a hard position to defend. The good news in all this bad news is this: all the bad news is tipping the entire world against Iran — a united front against Iran appears to be developing.

In the U.S., another phenomenon is likely to hurt the Iranian cause — the liberal Democrats are trying hard to get to the right of the Bush administration on the question of Iran. I’ll wager this is one the mullahs did not anticipate! When we have Hillary and Kerry accusing President Bush of being too soft on Iran it seems like almost anything is possible.

Cheney, in his AIPAC speech, made the point that one certain truth in the world we live in is that President Bush is a man of his word. At least on the War on Terror, I am perfectly willing to grant Mr. Cheney that point. The follow up, of course, is that President Bush has repeatedly stated that Iran will not be allowed to acquire nuclear weapons. Not “shouldn’t be allowed", but “will not be allowed.” When the man of his word makes a commitment like that, and the other side won’t voluntarily back down, then what’s left? I think the only remaining possibility is military action.

Donald Rumsfeld, in a question-and-answer session yesterday, made a related point. A reporter questioned him about the recent reports of sophisticated Iranian-made IEDs (bombs) being discovered in Iraq. Both Rumsfeld and General Pace (who was also present) talked about what these bombs were, and why we were sure they were coming from Iran. Then Mr. Rumsfeld said this: that he believed the Iranians would look back at this decision to aid the insurgents in Iraq and regret their decision to do so. He wouldn’t elaborate any more, but he’d made his point. One might legitimately ask whether that was posturing for propoganda effect, or whether that was a foreshadowing of future U.S. action. Knowing Mr. Rumsfeld’s track record, I’d bet on the foreshadowing.

I’m much more comfortable with the future’s possibilities when I see the world’s governments looking more and more united in opposition to Iran than I was when it appeared that the U.S. was a lonely voice in this particular wilderness. If nothing else, the supportive political environment makes unilateral — and possibly radical — action by the U.S. or Israel more likely. I can only think of two courses of action likely to be effective: military action (and this is a far larger and riskier course of action against Iran than it was against Iraq), and “regime change”. We’ve been told repeatedly that by and large the people of Iran do not support the mullahtocracy there. If this is true, then the preconditions for regime change are in place — and if we can help it along, wonderful.

So I’m actually feeling better about the Iranian threat, after all this “bad news”. Are you?

Tuesday, March 7, 2006

Puppy Journal

The latest from Sheila Miller:

The puppies were 3-weeks old as of Sunday. They weigh between 3 1/4 and 3 3/4 pounds each.

Their third week was a big one for them. Between 14 and 21 days old, several little miracles happened:

1. Eyes fully open and responsive

2. Can pee and poop on their own.

3. Ears open as evidenced by the first startle reactions to sound.

4. Have started wandering around the bedroom instead of staying put on their blanket while I clean the Dura-Whelp. :-)

5. Have noticed each other, especially each other’s noses.

6. Their milk teeth erupted!

7. They had their first nail trim.

This current week, going on 4-weeks old, is also a big one as they make the transition into real puppies. This is the week where I will see if they are interested in the weaning process. Picabo’s first litter wasn’t interested at all at this age. Puppies have to be hungry to try food. Picabo is too good of a provider. They will also become more curious about everything and more playful with each other. The game we can play now is the one where I kneel down half in/half out of the whelping box (not a very glamorous position) and the puppies come to me and explore my hair, face (take off the glasses!), and crawl over my arms. As each day goes by, I will be looking for signs of escape. I’ve given them their first toys - soft baby rattles - and they bite on the toys' little ears. They need to have more little adventures out of the whelping box now that they are comfortable in the bedroom. I put them on a blanket in the living room and they definitely knew they were somewhere else. They cried a little, wandered a little, and then piled up and went to sleep. Once they are comfortable in that room, I will set up an x-pen in there so the whole family can watch TV (is anything on??).

Let me tell you about my new x-pen for the living room. I bought it a couple of years ago from a gardening supply company. It is a 4-panel compost bin. Each panel is vinyl covered and is 28” high and 35 1/2” wide. It comes with clever connectors but I just use zip ties to hold it together. I bought two of them (8 panels) to keep the dogs off of my tomatoes (doesn’t work on chipmunks). I was excited about its potential use for puppies because of its height. I’m not a tall person and regular x-pens are hard for me to reach over and pick up a puppy. I should be able to reach over this. Because each panel is separate, I can overlap them to get exactly the size I what. If I put the ties on loosely, it will even fold up and out of the way.

The puppies are trying to suck the life out of Picabo but she is holding up very well. She is thin but still has flesh covering her bones. She is eating very well. She is on track to consume between 70 and 80 pounds of puppy food from her second trimester until weaning. Wow! That doesn’t include all of the yogurt, cheese, meat, eggs, and other snacks I give her. She is, however, quite bald. Her body has no intention of diverting any food to hair production. Time enough for that later. She comes outside with the other dogs and goes on walks with us. She is doing very well. I, on the other hand, am not. I’ve been fighting a virus or combination of viruses since a couple of days before the puppies were born. Every school is a cesspool of microbes. They usually miss me but not this year. The latest incarnation is in the form of laryngitis. Five days without any voice at all - just air. :-) I taught one day like that and called it quits. I’m about 75% now and will go back to school tomorrow. Raising a litter a puppies during the school year is tough. My life would be so much easier if I had a husband with a job, a wife with upper body strength, or a lover who could cook. Since I have none of those, I guess I will clean the Dura-Whelp again, run a load of laundry, and fix a bowl of cereal for supper. :-)

Sheila Miller

Wolftree Acres

Nevada, USA

sdmiller@the-onramp.net

http://www.wolftreeacres.homestead.com

Monday, March 6, 2006

GITMO Project

Captain Ed Morrisey (of Captain’s Quarters blog) is trying to harness the minds in blogosphere to analyze a small mountain of paperwork about the prisoners at GITMO. This paperwork was just released publicly by the Department of Defense. Shortly after the paperwork was released, two lawyers for some of the GITMO prisoners (Mark and Joshua Denbeaux) released a study purporting to analyze the released paperwork.

From the study by Mark and Joshua Denbeaux:

1. Fifty-five percent (55%) of the detainees are not determined to have committed any hostile acts against the United States or its coalition allies.

2. Only 8% of the detainees were characterized as al Qaeda fighters. Of the remaining detainees, 40% have no definitive connection with al Qaeda at all and 18% are have no definitive affiliation with either al Qaeda or the Taliban.

3. The Government has detained numerous persons based on mere affiliations with a large number of groups that in fact, are not on the Department of Homeland Security terrorist watchlist. Moreover, the nexus between such a detainee and such organizations varies considerably. Eight percent are detained because they are deemed “fighters for;” 30% considered “members of;” a large majority - 60% - are detained merely because they are “associated with” a group or groups the Government asserts are terrorist organizations. For 2% of the prisoners, a nexus to any terrorist group is not identified by the Government.

4. Only 5% of the detainees were captured by United States forces. 86% of the detainees were arrested by either Pakistan or the Northern Alliance and turned over to United States custody. This 86% of the detainees captured by Pakistan or the Northern Alliance were handed over to the United States at a time in which the United States offered large bounties for capture of suspected enemies.

5. Finally, the population of persons deemed not to be enemy combatants - mostly Uighers - are in fact accused of more serious allegations than a great many persons still deemed to be enemy combatants.

One might reasonably expect the lawyers for such defendants to make a case for their detention being unjustified. <sarcasm> Therefore one might also reasonably expect that a study by such attorneys might be the tiniest bit biased </sarcasm>. On the other hand, the circumstances of the “detainees” at GITMO are murky enough that I’d like to know myself what’s really going on there. And so would Captain Ed:

From Captain Ed:

In order for a study to have credibility, the results have to be replicable. That means that another group would have to spend the time to review and tally the same data that the Denbeauxs analyzed and determine if their numbers add up the same. Unfortunately, that sounds a little ambitious for one blogger. However, my good friend King Banaian at SCSU Scholars suggested to me that a blogswarm review — such as the one that Hugh Hewitt ran for the review of the John Roberts documentation — would work quickly through the stack of paperwork presented by the DoD.

What I propose is to have bloggers volunteer to review the data in the PDF files at the DoD link. We need to tally the SOEs to see how many include allegations of hostile acts, the type of affiliation for each detainee, and whether the SOE included mitigating information (found in Paragraph 4). Rather than look just for 3b, we need to review all of Paragraph 3 for the complete context of the threat presented by each detainee, at least according to the SOE.

This sounded like a worthy effort to me, so I signed up. Captain Ed sent me my assignment, which I’ve returned, with this comment:

After scanning this summary it was obvious that, as I expected, there was not enough information to reach an independent judgment. So I adopted this attitude as I read: I accepted the statements of fact as facts, and I interpreted as best I could any descriptions of what people actually said. I then made my best judgment as to the items you asked us to tabulate, based on the belief I had after reading the whole SOE. Most of these judgments could easily be debated by reasonable people, of course.

I feel like I’ve just taken a look at an alien (to me) culture from some distance, using a poor telescope. I was struck by the repeated descriptions of “recruitment” into jihad by religious figures. How strange, and frightening, such religious fervor! But these summaries are so shallow (as summaries usually are) that one cannot get any sense of the actual people (the “detainees", I mean) — though it was easy to see, in some cases, the hostility of the officer writing up the summary, especially in some of the cases where the detainees have exhibited awful behavior in GITMO.

One thing that jumped out at me: the mitigations nearly all fall into one of two categories — either a simple denial (e.g., “I was not an Al Qaida"), or completely irrelevant (e.g., “If released I will go home to my farm and get married."). The denials are not really informative, as (obviously) either a guilty or an innocent party is likely to deny the crime. To me, this basically complete absence of legitimate mitigating factors is the most compelling argument for bias in the process. If the process was fair, I’d expect to see things like “My good friend Dave is American” or “Here are the other five religious missions I went on before I was accidentally caught up in this mess in Afghanistan”. But those are not there at all. Of course, the alternative explanation for the absence of legitimate mitigating factors is that they are genuinely missing — because the detainees are in fact guilty — and that the U.S. officers acting on their behalf stretched hard to find the few mitigating factors they did list. I hope like hell its the latter (and the other evidence for guilt inclines me that way), but I don’t see a way to prove it from the SOEs…

This was a very interesting exercise to participate in, and I eagerly await the results. My little piece of the exercise was far too small a sample to draw any conclusions from.

If you’re interested in seeing some of the raw data yourself, they’re publicly available here.

Saturday, March 4, 2006

Hummer Blogging

We have one species of hummingbird (Anna’s, Calypte anna) that stays with us year-round, and the male of that species is the star of our springtime mating plumage show. I took photos this morning of this single male perching in our fig tree (yes, we have deciduous trees in Southern California!). He just happened to be the only one brave or foolish enough to get close to me and my camera; I’d estimate we have between 40 and 50 pairs of Anna’s hummingbirds visiting our feeders daily. The males are extraordinarily showy when they directly face you (as you can see in the rightmost photo); when even slighly off-angle much of the color disappears.

As usual, click on the small pictures for a larger view…

I’ve never found a nest for an Anna’s hummingbird, even though they are by far the most common hummingbird here. When walking in the chaparral, at any time of year, the chances are very high that any hummingbirds you see (at least in our area) are Anna’s. I’ve searched through brush in the springtime near where I see them perch, but have never managed to spot a nest. I have found two black-chinned hummingbird nests, both in the dead wood of manzanitas on the edge of a clearing — easy to spot.

Perched on the feeder at right is (I believe) a juvenile male Anna’s. His colors are a bit off because of the reflected red light from the feeder, and the reflected green light from the transparent “hummer juice” container on the feeder. If you look at the larger version of that picture, you’ll see it’s very detailed (and even that was reduced for reproduction on the web). That’s what you get when you’re 7 feet from the bird with a high-powered telephoto! On the left is a female hummingbird, and these are notoriously difficult to identify. I believe this is a juvenile female Anna’s, however. The adult female Anna’s have a surprising amount of bright red color on their throats, especially in the springtime.

Finally there are these two shots of a black-chinned hummingbird (Archilochus alexandri), an adult male. This species leaves each winter and returns each spring. The “black-chinned” name is a bit misleading; if you catch these fellows just right (which I didn’t in these pictures), they have a brilliant, very saturated purple patch on about the lower two-thirds of that black chin. While they are not the showiest hummer here, I think they are actually the most beautiful of the four commons species here, when you catch them just right. He’s looking a little disheveled here, but that’s only because he spent 15 minutes in our bird bath just prior to perching on our fig tree to dry out. The black-chinned hummers appear to be the smallest of our hummingbirds, though Sibley says they’re about average (3.75” long). The males have a spectacular diving loop display, which they will repeat endlessly during the spring seasons. They tend to use the same spot over and over; if you go lie on the ground under where one is displaying the effect is quite dramatic. The hummer will start out perhaps 60 or 70 feet high; a little speck flickering against the blue sky. Then suddenly he’ll dive straight down, straight at your face if you’re positioned well. Then just a few feet off the ground he’ll pull out of the dive, in a “U” shaped curve that ends up with him going straight up, just a few feet away from where he just went down. He makes some distinctive noises during this display that I won’t even try to describe. When I first saw this display, the spring after we moved out into the chaparral, I though the hummers were suicidal — they are moving fast, and it doesn’t look safe…

Friday, March 3, 2006

Appeasement

Chop higher.

Heh, as the Instapundit would say…

Click for a larger and much clearer view…

So Sad

Not long ago, Michael Griffin (NASA’s administrator) promised Congress and the American people that Bush’s ambitious manned space program initiative could be accomplished without sacrificing “one thin dime” of NASA’s hard science budget.

He lied.

The budget, made public a few days ago, surprised many with its drastic hard science cutbacks. Many of the most interesting, most promising science missions were delayed indefinitely — budget-speak for canceled, but hopefully without the negative PR.

From the New York Times:

The cuts come to $3 billion over the next five years, even as NASA’s overall spending grows by 3.2 percent this year, to $16.8 billion.

Among the casualties in the budget, released last month, are efforts to look for habitable planets and perhaps life elsewhere in the galaxy, an investigation of the dark energy that seems to be ripping the universe apart, bringing a sample of Mars back to Earth and exploring for life under the ice of Jupiter’s moon Europa — as well as numerous smaller programs and individual research projects that astronomers say are the wellsprings of new science and new scientists.

This is so sad. As Carl Sagan might have said, billions and billions of dollars are about to be spent on getting a few humans to the moon. There might even be a permanent settlement there (that’s the goal), which I’ll translate into a permanent weight on NASA’s budget, much as the Space Shuttle and the International Space Station have turned out to be.

And how frustrating! The “romance” of manned space missions completely trumps hard science. If you believe the politicians are accurately reflecting their constituencies (an arguable proposition, to be sure), then the majority of the American people would rather spend $40 billion to $60 billion on manned space missions that will do nothing useful whatsoever than spend $10 billion on hard science missions that will greatly expand our understanding of the universe.

I guess it’s just another of the numerous ways in which I’m out of sync with the rest of the world…

Hugo and CITGO

The image at right shows Cindy Sheehan in the friendly embrace of Hugo Chavez, the neo-commie “elected” dictator of Venezuela. If you’re not familiar with Hugo, the fact that he treats Cindy Sheehan as an ally speaks volumes — but even worse is Hugo’s buddying up to Fidel Castro, Mohammar Khadafi, and the crazy, vicious, holocaust-denying, Jew-hating President of Iran. Hugo has been running Venezuela as his personal fiefdom, using violent thugs to rig elections or to simply kill his opponents. He is in complete control of his country; in every sense a true dictator.

And Hugo owns CITGO. Lock, stock, and barrel. Because CITGO is 100% owned by Petróleos de Venezuela S.A., which is a corporation entirely owned by the country of Venezuela.

Just in case you’re not familiar with huggable Hugo, here’s a sample of this nutcase’s rantings:

“Enough already with the imperialist aggression!”, Chavez said, according to the January 31 Caracas Daily Journal, listing countries from Panama to Iraq where the US military has intervened. “Down with the US empire!”

“We need militaries that don’t trample over [us] and that don’t sell themselves to the empire”, Chavez said. “If the empire of the United States thinks to come here and invade Venezuela, you can be certain that the 100-year war will begin and we will defeat the North American empire on this land”, Chavez added, to loud applause.

Lovely. And this guy is right on our doorstep — Venezuela’s coastline is the Caribbean!

There have been calls over the past few months for a boycott of CITGO. I’m generally reluctant to promote boycotts, as it’s all too easy for them to hit unintended targets. In the case of CITGO this is also true, for most of the distributors of CITGO products (such as 7/11) are not Venezuelan companies, and a boycott of CITGO will hit them. But…those distributors have a choice about what products they carry; they can switch to another supplier. And since CITGO itself is a 100% Venezuelan state-owned company, a boycott of CITGO will score a direct hit on Hugo, where it will hurt him the most — his pocketbook ('cause I don’t think we have a good way to kick him in the balls). I couldn’t verify this on the web, but I believe it’s true that the United States is the largest customer for Petróleos de Venezuela, so a CITGO boycott would definitely have an impact.

Boycott CITGO goods! Examine those gas pumps carefully; many retailers sell CITGO products under their own name, but the pumps are usually labeled somewhere with the actual supplier’s name…

M101

I wonder if Charles Messier ever even imagined that someday his catalog of beautiful objects in the sky could be seen in such detail?

From APOD (of course!):

Big, beautiful spiral galaxy M101 is one of the last entries in Charles Messier’s famous catalog, but definitely not one of the least. About 170,000 light-years across, this galaxy is enormous, almost twice the size of our own Milky Way galaxy. M101 was also one of the original spiral nebulae observed by Lord Rosse’s large 19th century telescope, the Leviathan of Parsontown. Assembled from 51 exposures recorded by the Hubble Space Telescope in the 20th and 21st centuries, with additional data from ground based telescopes, this mosaic of M101 is touted as the largest, most detailed spiral galaxy view ever released from Hubble. The sharp image shows stunning features along the galaxy’s face-on disk of stars and dust along with background galaxies, some visible right through M101 itself. Also known as the Pinwheel Galaxy, M101 lies within the boundaries of the northern constellation Ursa Major, about 25 million light-years away.

If you’re not familiar with Charles Messier and his famous catalog of celestial objects, you might be interested to know more about him. Wikipedia has short articles on both Messier and his catalog. The photo at right is a visual catalog of all 110 “Messier Objects”.

As usual, click on the small photo for a larger view…

Puppy Pictures!

Sheila Miller arranged for a friend to scan her original photos, and somehow an additional picture (of Cosmo, the dad) snuck in. So here are the puppy pictures again, but this time in a bit higher resolution. These have all been processed to bring out as much detail as possible in the puppies, which means in some cases sacrificing the natural contrasts and colors to some extent. Enjoy!

As usual, click on the small picture for a larger view…

Thursday, March 2, 2006

DOPE

Put down your drink before you read this, less you splatter slightly used beverage all over your monitor. This was written by John Stumpf, a former Chief Information Officer, now retired:

Preparatory Work

So it has happened: you have fired up your Dell PC, and - nothing. Or the dreaded “cannot find boot drive” or something like that. Now you are forced into the unenviable position of having to call Dell Off-shore Hardware Support. Look at it as a journey, one on which you will be tested, much like Job or Arthur Dent. You will descend into the ninth circle, but with the proper preparation, tools and attitude, you will return, a better person for it.

First, before you call, prepare. Raid your kids' library and find some simple reading primers along the lines of “See Spot Run.” This will help you speak in non-complex sentences and monosyllabic words.

Make an appointment for that root canal you have been putting off. After what you are about to experience, you will look forward to it.

Buy a speakerphone; it’s tough to stay rational when your neck is cramped.

When you are ready to MAKE THE CALL, go to the bathroom, take an aspirin, get a book or crossword, stock up on water and nibbles (preferably ones with high sugar content and no nutritional value; Twinkies are good). Shoo the kids out of your den; it’s possible that they will hear things that could cause serious psychological issues later.

Do your relaxation exercises; take a sip of water; remember Dan Rather’s closing, “Courage.” And MAKE THE CALL.

What Happens Next

The first thing that you will get is a recorded announcement saying that you can go to support.dell.com online to get help. This is your first test. Refrain from screaming that your PC is broken and you can’t GET to the Internet. This is where it is handy to have a towel to bite on, so your family doesn’t hear you screaming at a recording.

You may also be asked to enter your “Express Service Code.” (The discussion of why you have an “Express” Service Code when you are spending a long time on hold is best put off for another time.)

Eventually you will get to a person. You will tell him/her why you are calling, and most likely you will be told you have to call someone else. They will offer to transfer you, but before they do, GET THE EXENSION NUMBER. This is very important, especially when (not if) you get cut off. Note that it is a seven-digit extension number.

While waiting, pause and ponder the size and complexity of a company that needs an extension number the size of your phone number.

Now you are getting close. You will eventually get to someone who after getting your name, address, problem, and again, Express Service code, will say the magic words, “I can help you with that problem.” You have now contacted a Dell Offshore Personal Expert - a DOPE.

Some notes on this part of the process:

* The DOPE will probably call you by your first name, because he/she wants to be your new best friend.

* He/she will profusely thank you at every step of the way for the same reason.

* He/she will have a notable American name like Patrick, Matthew or even a Shaun. Do not react to this.

But congratulations; YOU HAVE REACHED SOMEONE WHO IS TRYING TO HELP YOU! You reached the ninth circle, and all you have to do is return.

The Return

What happens now will vary depending on your problem. But here are some guidelines for dealing with the DOPES.

* Do not yell at them. Aside from the fact that it is rude, I think the phone system has a volume limiter that will cut you off. Bite the towel instead.

* Do not try sarcasm; DOPES don’t understand it. Again, bite the towel.

* Ditto humor.

* Do not use words like “escalate” or “supervisor.” In my case, they were greeted by a frosty silence. My guess is that they sound like obscenities in the local language.

* Do not ask if there is U.S.-based support. You will be told that there is “no U.S.-based Dell support."

* You may be told that the DOPE will take personal responsibility for your problem. Loosely translated, this means you will never hear from him/her again.

There is Hope

At some point in this process, you may reach a Newly Oriented Dell Off-shore Personal Expert - a NO-DOPE. This is a person that has recently joined Dell who hasn’t been fully trained and therefore will approach your problem in a friendly, knowledgeable and professional manner. He/she will solve your problem in less time than it took to write this.

The moral of the story is to keep trying; eventually you will reach a NO-DOPE.

You Have Done It

See, I told you that you could do it. Let the kids and pets back in, throw out the towel, and start using complex sentences and polysyllabic words again. And late that night, after everyone has gone to bed, break out the 12-year-old stuff, and toast yourself. Tomorrow you can reload all your programs and restore your data from your backup. You do have a backup, don’t you?

(All of the events related here are based on my experience with two incidents. The process was so frustrating that I probably will not buy another Dell. And of course apologies to Dante, Doug Adams, Greek mythology and those at Dell Off-shore Support who are great.)

I can definitely relate to this <smile>…

Kids

As I looked at these images (thanks, Jim — I think…), the thought that came first to mind is that these kids go home to momma and poppa, at least occasionally. I believe I can safely say that I don’t know any parents who would allow their child to do something like this to themselves.

But there must be parents who do. Who are they? Enquiring minds want to know…

These photos reminded me of a personal experience… I used to stay overnight frequently in Lake Forest, California, and in the mornings it was my habit to visit the Starbucks next door to my motel for my coffee. Morning coffee, for me, is a necessity, not a luxury. Many mornings the clerk was a young woman I named “Metal Woman” because she was festooned with metal parts. She was inordinately proud of her metallic accessories — dozens of them on her face and ears, about 10 in her tongue, and suspicious looking bumps nearly everywhere under her clothing. On one memorable visit, Metal Woman was chatting with a non-metallic friend, very casually and openly talking about her metalwork in — ahem — places that aren’t usually discussed in public. I heard quite a few details that I really wish I had never been educated about, such as the hygenic challenges raised by metal piercings frequently bathed in urine.

Somehow my coffee didn’t seem quite so tasty on that morning…

Puppy Pictures!

Is there anything cuter than a puppy? I think not…

These pictures (click for a larger view) are of each puppy in the litter, along with a group photo of Picaboo (the mama) and the whole crowd.

One of these will join our family, but we don’t know which one yet…

I want them all!

The Anti-Cartoon

One of my readers (thanks, Simon!) forwarded the cartoon at right (click for a larger view). It notes — as many writers have — that reaction in the Mulsim world to the now-famous Danish cartoons of Mohammed seems very much out of proportion, and especially so when compared to the utter lack of outrage from the Muslim world to the terrorist actions of the radical Muslims. Where was this outrage when, for example, terrorists bombed the trains in Madrid? While there were Muslim clerics who denounced this bombing (which I’m just picking on as an example), the general reaction of the common person “on the street” in the Islamic world seemed to be somewhere between indifference and delight that the “infidels” had been attacked. And now a cartoon has hundreds of thousands of people enraged to the point where they violently demonstrate?

As TigerHawk has pointed out, there is an asymmetry to this that is both offensive and chilling. It offends our Western sense of fairness, and it is chilling because it reveals the truth under all the posturing: at its core, the Islamic world is not tolerant of non-Muslims, and in fact would be happy if we all just died. I was reminded of this recently as I read that the Muslim youth in Paris who slit the throat of an innocent Jewish boy yelled in joy “I have killed my Jew — now I will go to heaven!” as he danced about on the stairs to his apartment, drenched in the blood of his victim.

His way of speaking truth to power, I suppose…

Wednesday, March 1, 2006

Old Harold

I was having trouble with my computer. So I called Harold the computer guy, to come over. Harold clicked a couple of buttons and solved the problem. He gave me a bill for a minimum service call. As he was walking away, I called after him, “So, what was wrong?” He replied, “It was an ID ten T error.” I didn’t want to appear stupid, but nonetheless inquired, “An, ID ten T error? What’s that .. in case I need to fix it again?” Harold grinned.... “Haven’t you ever heard of an ID ten T error before?” “No,” I replied. “Write it down,” he said, “and I think you’ll figure it out."

So I wrote down … I D 1 0 T

I used to like Old Harold.

The Manifesto

And was said very well, indeed. And published in the same Danish paper (Jyllands-Posten) that published the cartoons:

MANIFESTO: Together facing the new totalitarianism

After having overcome fascism, Nazism, and Stalinism, the world now faces a new totalitarian global threat: Islamism.

We, writers, journalists, intellectuals, call for resistance to religious totalitarianism and for the promotion of freedom, equal opportunity and secular values for all.

The recent events, which occurred after the publication of drawings of Muhammed in European newspapers, have revealed the necessity of the struggle for these universal values. This struggle will not be won by arms, but in the ideological field. It is not a clash of civilisations nor an antagonism of West and East that we are witnessing, but a global struggle that confronts democrats and theocrats.

Like all totalitarianisms, Islamism is nurtured by fears and frustrations. The hate preachers bet on these feelings in order to form battalions destined to impose a liberticidal and unegalitarian world. But we clearly and firmly state: nothing, not even despair, justifies the choice of obscurantism, totalitarianism and hatred. Islamism is a reactionary ideology which kills equality, freedom and secularism wherever it is present. Its success can only lead to a world of domination: man’s domination of woman, the Islamists' domination of all the others. To counter this, we must assure universal rights to oppressed or discriminated people.

We reject cultural relativism, which consists in accepting that men and women of Muslim culture should be deprived of the right to equality, freedom and secular values in the name of respect for cultures and traditions. We refuse to renounce our critical spirit out of fear of being accused of “Islamophobia", an unfortunate concept which confuses criticism of Islam as a religion with stigmatisation of its believers.

We plead for the universality of freedom of expression, so that a critical spirit may be exercised on all continents, against all abuses and all dogmas.

We appeal to democrats and free spirits of all countries that our century should be one of Enlightenment, not of obscurantism.

12 signatures

Ayaan Hirsi Ali

Chahla Chafiq

Caroline Fourest

Bernard-Henri Lévy

Irshad Manji

Mehdi Mozaffari

Maryam Namazie

Taslima Nasreen

Salman Rushdie

Antoine Sfeir

Philippe Val

Ibn Warraq

You can add my signature to this.

Hat tip: Michelle Malkin.

Tuesday, February 28, 2006

Abortion Position

A couple of weeks ago, one of my readers (thanks, Larry!) emailed me a link to a study on how abortion affects the crime rate. He started by saying “Not sure where you stand on abortion…” — and I could hardly believe that, because abortion is one of a few major social issues that ignited my interest in politics a few (ok, many) years ago…

So in this post, I’ll address the study first, and then discuss a bit of my stand on abortion. It’s still one of the most difficult issues for me to wrap my brain around.

The study (which you can download and read here) supports the idea that legalized abortion lowers the crime rate, and hints at that fact as justification for legalized abortion. The study starts with the interesting correllation between abortion becoming legal in the U.S., and the decline in the crime rate starting roughly 18 years later. It continues by examining possible mechanisms and testing them statistically. I can summarize the whole thing rather crudely this way: legalized abortion lowers crime by lowering the number of people in the age group most likely to commit crime, and even importantly, in the socio-economic categories most likely to commit crime. They cite the example that poor blacks commit a disproportionate share of crime; they also have a much higher rate of abortions.

I found the study fairly convincing as to the connection between legalized abortion and reduced crime. James Taranto has made a very similar case (though certainly not as robustly studied) for something he calls the “Roe effect” — the conjecture that legalized abortion leads to fewer liberals, as liberals are the group most likely to choose to abort a baby.

But I did not find the study convincing as justification for legalized abortion. A thought experiment will demonstrate why. Suppose we instituted a new policy: the first time a person was convicted of a crime, they are summarily executed, right there in the courtroom after the verdict is read. How horrible, you say! I’d wager that new policy would get almost no support. And yet, I’m certain that the new policy would result in a much-reduced rate of crime, as we know from decades of rigorous study that the vast majority of crime is committed by repeat offenders.

The fact that a policy results in reduced crime rates does not justify that policy, ipso facto. The policy in the thought experiment would be (hopefully) universally rejected because it is immoral — that the immoral policy has societal benefit is irrelevant to the debate.

I apply the same logic to the question of abortion and conclude that this study is irrelevant to the debate about the morality of abortion.

I can summarize my position on abortion very inexactly this way: I believe abortion is immoral in most circumstances. I have some very fuzzy edges on my thinking, however, which derive from what I’ll call the “timeline dilemma”. I’m certainly not the first to point out this problem. The sophisticated philosophical thinkers will think me provincial and simple as I articulate this, but that’s their problem <smile>. Here’s the timeline dilemma:

Starting at the early end of the timeline…if a couple decides to use contraception to prevent their sexual activity from conceiving a child, do I see any problem with that? No, I don’t. And if I did, I see a classic slippery-slope problem there — for if I thought (as the Catholic Church does) that contraception was immoral, does it not follow rather directly that any conscious avoidance of pregancy by a couple is also immoral? The Catholic Church says the “rhythm method” is ok, but from a moral perspective I see precious little difference between that and using a contraceptive.

Ok, let’s take it the other way, then. If I’m ok with contraceptives, then what about 1 second after conception? Do I see a moral problem with that? Well, truthfully, no — it seems pretty clear that at that point we don’t actually have child there, and aborting a pregancy at that point, from a moral perspective, doesn’t seem substantively different than contraception to me. Remember, I’m not religious, and I’m looking at this as a secular, but moral, person (even though Dr. Laura would say that’s not possible!).

So there’s one end of the timeline. Let’s go to the other end of it — when a child is born. Do I have a moral problem with killing a baby as it lies there screaming in its crib? Yes (despite my frequently saying — in jest, mind you — that I’m with W. C. Fields: I like my children roasted or boiled). Walk it back — do I have a problem killing a baby one second before birth. Well, yes; from that moral perspctive, I see no particular difference between killing the crying baby and killing the one that’s about to be born.

Two ends to the timeline, two different conclusion about the morality of abortion at those points. Now comes the hard part — what about the time in between those ends of the timeline? If I hold different views on the morality of abortion at each end of the timeline, then inescapably there must be a point in between the ends where my viewpoint flips — for this is a binary issue; abortion (at any given moment in time) surely is either immoral or moral; it can’t be “partly moral", for there is no such thing.

Sometimes (as pro-abortionists are wont to emphasize) there are factors that complicate the moral calculus. Suppose the child is the product of a rape? Suppose it is defective in some profound way that renders a useful human life impossible? And so on; there are many such factors that I’m perfectly willing to throw into the equation — and these, combined with the timeline, are what make this such a difficult issue for me.

There are also factors — sometimes allegedly moral factors — that I believe should not be part of the equation at all. I don’t believe that the mother’s economic situation or marriage status helps us reach a decision on the morality of abortion, on the same reasoning that leads me to conclude that a reduced crime rate offers no justification. And while the pregnancy may simply be unwanted by the mother, I see that as a very unfortunate circumstance that doesn’t speak to the morality of abortion at all. Feminists argue — really, they hold it as an article of faith — that women have the moral right to make any choice they want about their own body, and that prior to birth, a baby is just another part of their own body. By that same reasoning, it would be moral for me to decide not to help a dying person I happen upon, if it inconvenienced me. I don’t buy that line of moral reasoning.

So where on the timeline does my moral stance on abortion flip? The uncomfortable truth is that I have no idea how to determine that point. The only certainty I have is that the further along the timeline a preganancy goes, the more (and more) uncomfortable I get with the morality of an abortion.

In the end, I retreat to safety. “Abortion", in this context, is just another word for legalized killing. The only other form of killing widely (but not universally) recognized as both legal and moral is the execution of criminals. There, to assure the morality of our actions and to assuage our consciences, we go to extremes to make certain we make no mistakes. I see no moral alternative to those extremes for so long as the death penalty is legal. And I believe that’s the safe course with abortion as well; hence my position that abortion is “immoral in most circumstances” (and therefore should be outlawed).

By “in most circumstances", I’m most definitely weasling out a bit. For example, in those (fortunately quite rare) cases where a pregnancy would certainly kill the mother, my own moral calculus is that the mother’s right to live trumps the baby’s right to obtain independent life. Clearly someone might reasonably disagree with that; its a moral judgment, not an absolute. It gets fuzzier if the mother is put at risk by the continued pregnancy; now the moral calculus for me is considerably more complex, and I’d want to understand the probabilities before rendering a moral judgment. There are any number of other circumstances that I can imagine as well. For example, imagine a woman was raped, became pregnant, and then was held prisoner for four months before she escaped. I can think of many circumstances (all uncommon) that make it impossible for me to support a flat-out, no-exceptions ban on abortion. But I can think of no circumstances that allow me to think of abortion as a moral choice that women should be able to make independently.

The legal environment I’d like to see would be one in which abortions more than some very short time (say 30 days) after conception were illegal, but in which a process existed for exceptions to be granted. In this hypothetical environment, requests for abortions would be expeditiously heard (for time is very much of the essence in these cases) by a technically qualified judge (or panel, better yet) who explicitly weighed the moral issues of each such case, weighing the rights of the baby and the rights of the mother where they were in conflict. I further believe that the bar for filing for such an exception should be quite high; that evidence of a moral conflict should be part of the requirement.

Watching the political polarization on the abortion issue, I suspect there are only two likely outcomes, even in the long run: either complete laissez faire, as today, or completely outlawing it. I don’t see much chance of the polar extremes working with each other for any sort of a compromise, middle-road approach to the question. Not that my suggestion would be considered a “compromise” by the “pro-choice” crowd…

Rules for Life

Rules for Life:

1. You really need only two tools: WD-40 and duct tape. If it doesn’t move and it should, use WD-40. If it moves and it shouldn’t, use the duct tape.

2. Everyone seems normal until you get to know them.

3. And finally, be really good to your family and friends. You never know when you are going to need them to empty your bedpan!!!

— —

Tom’s addition for software engineers:

1. You really only need two tools: the delete key and red wine. If your program does something it shouldn’t do, use the delete key. If your program doesn’t do something that it should, drink red wine while coding until the program behaves as it should (or you don’t care).

Artist Soldier

Michael Fay is a Marine soldier, an officer, an accomplished artist, and a blogger. Quite the unusual combination!

At right are five examples of Michael’s work in Iraq (from where he has just returned), published in today’s Wall Street Journal. As Michael says on his blog, this is his 15 minutes of fame, and he seems to be relishing it. Who wouldn’t <smile>?

As usual, click on the small images for a larger view…

Puppy Journal

The puppies are 2-weeks old as of Sunday and have been put into rick rack.

1st born black male = white boy (2 1/2 pounds)

2nd born black male = yellow boy (2 1/4 pounds)

3rd born liver male = green boy (2 lbs, 10 ounces)

4th born liver male = blue boy (2 lbs, 10 ounces)

5th born black female = pink girl (2 3/4 pounds)

6th born liver female = purple girl (2 1/2 pounds)

Whether CBR or FS, every “pink girl” in every litter of mine has grown up and accomplished things in show or performance rings. All those girls were brown. This time around I put the pink rick rack on the black bitch. Not because I am picking her to be the “one” but because she needs the extra luck that goes with pink. She is the only puppy in the litter with clear white. Everyone else has black or liver ticking filling in their muzzles and/or toes. The white comes from both Cosmo and Picabo but the absence of ticking come from Cosmo. :-( I know it is way too early to worry about their color (it can take up to six months for facial white to fill in) but I can’t help but notice how “clean” she is compared to how “dirty” the rest are. Yellow boy, Blue boy, and Purple girl are going to basically be solid-colored dogs with a little white on their throats and chests. White boy might end up with a slight look of gray around his nose (like Picabo - you have to look for it). Green boy and Pink girl are wait and sees.

A lot has happened in the last week. They are up on their feet and wobbling a few steps forward and backward. Their eyes are open and at the very least, pink girl has shown signs of useful vision. I held her today by the window and she turned toward it, then she turned toward me. When Picabo was outside the Dura-Whelp’s gate, she wobbled toward the gate and made the first attempt at climbing over it (a pretty feeble attempt but she stood on three legs and put her other paw on the barrier). They are also very vocal the few seconds they are awake. They don’t cry but they make a baby barking sound.

Sunday was a big day. I took out the pig rails because they were threatening to become lethal. The puppies are now just big enough and mobile enough that they could get their necks caught between the rail and Picabo. I know because I had to rescue a couple of them Saturday night. I made yet another modification to the Dura-Whelp. I bought a piece of white marker board, used the whelping box’s removable door as a pattern, and cut two new door sizes. The doors slide into grooves and close off the opening. There is no inbetween. The gate is open or it is closed. I want the puppies in but I want Picabo to come and go as she pleases. The opening to the door is 7 inches high. I cut a door that now makes the opening 9 inches high. It is still easy for Picabo to step over but I won’t have to worry about escaping puppies this week. Next week will be another story. I made a second door that is 12 inches high. That one will only go in when I notice the puppies trying to get out. Picabo can hop over it but I don’t want her landing on a puppy. My hope is to keep them contained until they are four-weeks old and then move them into the x-pen. I’m not hopeful that they will last that long in the Dura-Whelp. The other big thing that happened on Sunday was that I moved back into my own room. Ahh, to sleep for six uninteruppted hours… The puppies don’t need me and Picabo wanted the bed in that room anyway. :-)

My oh my but I have had to invest a lot of time in that plastic box. I have it sitting on 1 1/2 inches of styrofoam for additional insulation (that will come out when the 12” door goes in), I have added additional Velcro to both the floor and the two pads I purchased. I made two more pads and I have made two replacement doors. I coded the pig rails with a Sharpie so when I use it again, I can line everything up the way I had it this time. The box is guaranteed for three years. That’s funny because it will be at least three years, maybe four before I use it again. :-)

Not much else has happened. Picabo has rejoined the family on our daily walks. I don’t have to supervise her toilet duties anymore. To say she is blowing her coat is an understatement. She scratches herself and oops, she is bald there. It will all grow back nice and black and shiny. I do have the pictures back from last week and I will make an album to put up in the list’s photo file.

Sheila Miller

Wolftree Acres

Nevada, USA

sdmiller@the-onramp.net

http://www.wolftreeacres.homestead.com